Matching the patient to IUI, IVF or ICSI
Doctors: the full version of this topic is in the Doctors’ Textbook. See page 12 on choosing between expectant care, OI, IUI and IVF, and page 31 on IUI indications. Also see page 41 on the indications for IVF and for ICSI. Embryologist path: this page is optional reading.
On this page you will learn
- The principle of the simplest effective treatment
- Which findings make IUI reasonable and which rule it out
- The usual reasons for IVF and for ICSI
- How age and time trying shift the choice
Start from the diagnosis
A treatment is chosen to get round a specific obstacle. Once the investigations on page 63 are back, write down in one line the likely cause or causes for this couple: ovulatory, tubal, male, endometriosis, uterine, unexplained or a combination. Then ask which treatment bypasses that obstacle with the least burden. Simpler steps come first when they have a reasonable chance; more complex steps come first when the simpler ones cannot work or when time is short.
The ladder of treatment
Correct the correctable
Treat thyroid disease and raised prolactin, advise on weight, smoking and alcohol, and time intercourse to the fertile window. For some couples nothing more is needed.
Ovulation induction
For a woman who does not ovulate regularly, with open tubes and adequate sperm, oral ovulation induction with scan monitoring (page 64) is the usual first step. The principles are on page 67.
IUI
IUI places a prepared sperm sample in the uterus near the time of ovulation (page 69). It needs at least one open, healthy tube and a sample that, after preparation, contains enough progressively motile sperm (page 14). Reasonable indications include:
- Unexplained infertility of shorter duration, with stimulation
- Mild male factor
- Ovulatory disorders that have not responded to timed intercourse alone
- Problems with intercourse or ejaculation, or cervical factors
- Use of donor sperm, within the law described on page 71
IUI is not appropriate when both tubes are blocked or damaged, when sperm numbers after preparation are very low, or when several well-conducted IUI cycles have already failed.
IVF
In IVF, eggs are collected and fertilised in the laboratory, and an embryo is transferred to the uterus. It bypasses the tubes completely. Common reasons include:
- Tubal blockage or damage
- Moderate or severe endometriosis
- Failed IUI cycles
- Reduced ovarian reserve or advancing age, where time matters
- A need for embryo testing (page 58) or for fertility preservation
ICSI
ICSI is a laboratory technique within IVF: a single sperm is injected into each mature egg (pages 28-34). The laboratory reasons for choosing it are set out on page 27.
From the clinic side, the main indications are a severe male factor, sperm retrieved surgically, previous fertilisation failure with conventional IVF, and frozen-thawed eggs. Cases planned for PGT are also an indication, where contamination by extra sperm must be avoided. ICSI is not automatically better than conventional IVF when the sperm is normal; it adds a procedure without a clear benefit in that situation.
Age and duration
A woman's age is the strongest single factor in the chance of conception, because egg number and quality decline. For an older woman, or one with a low ovarian reserve, spending many months on simpler treatment may cost more than it saves; moving earlier to IVF is often discussed. A young couple with a short duration can usually afford to try simpler steps first.
At the bench: writing the plan
- List the findings for both partners on one sheet.
- Write the working diagnosis in one line.
- Name the treatment and the reason it suits this diagnosis.
- State how many cycles you will try before reviewing the plan.
- Record what was explained to the couple, including other options and the risks, such as multiple pregnancy and OHSS (page 68).
- Confirm that consent will be taken in writing before treatment (page 71).
Common errors
- Offering IUI without confirming that a tube is open
- Repeating IUI many times without review
- Using ICSI by habit when sperm is normal
- Ignoring the woman's age when choosing the pace of treatment
Key points
- Start from the diagnosis, then choose the treatment that bypasses the obstacle with the least burden.
- IUI needs at least one open, healthy tube and enough progressively motile sperm after preparation.
- IVF bypasses the tubes completely.
- ICSI is not automatically better than conventional IVF when the sperm is normal.
- Egg number and quality decline with age, so for an older woman moving earlier to IVF is often discussed.
Check yourself
What two findings must be in place before IUI is reasonable?
At least one open, healthy tube, and a sample that, after preparation, contains enough progressively motile sperm.
Give three indications for IVF and three for ICSI.
IVF, any three of:
- tubal blockage or damage;
- moderate or severe endometriosis;
- failed IUI cycles;
- reduced ovarian reserve or advancing age, where time matters;
- a need for embryo testing or for fertility preservation.
ICSI, any three of:
- a severe male factor;
- sperm retrieved surgically;
- previous fertilisation failure with conventional IVF;
- frozen-thawed eggs;
- cases planned for PGT.
Why is ICSI not routinely chosen when the semen analysis is normal?
It is not automatically better than conventional IVF when the sperm is normal. It adds a procedure without a clear benefit in that situation.
How does a woman's age change the order of treatment?
Egg number and quality decline with age. For an older woman, or one with a low ovarian reserve, many months of simpler treatment may cost more than they save, so moving earlier to IVF is often discussed. A young couple with a short duration can usually try simpler steps first.
From page 27: Which steps of natural fertilisation does ICSI bypass?
Passing through the cumulus, binding to the zona, the acrosome reaction, penetrating the zona and fusing with the oolemma (page 27).
From page 14: How do you calculate the total progressively motile count of a washed sample?
Multiply the final volume by the concentration by the proportion of progressive sperm. Use the final resuspension volume, not the volume of the original semen (page 14).
Questions on this page
Is IVF always the next step after IUI?
Not always. The plan is reviewed after an agreed number of cycles, taking into account the diagnosis, age and the couple's wishes.
Is ICSI used for every IVF cycle?
No. ICSI is chosen for specific reasons such as a severe male factor or previous fertilisation failure. With normal sperm, conventional IVF is often suitable.
Why write the plan down?
So that the couple, the clinic and the laboratory share the same understanding of the treatment, the reason for it and when it will be reviewed.
The Genesis ART Textbook is teaching text for trainees and doctors of the Genesis ART Training Academy. It is not treatment advice and not a laboratory standard operating procedure; every technique is learned under supervision. Page numbers never change.
