Blastocyst grading (Gardner)
On this page you will learn
- The three parts of a blastocyst that you grade
- The six expansion stages of the Gardner system
- The A, B and C grades for inner cell mass and trophectoderm
- How to write, check and agree a blastocyst grade
What you are looking at
On page 36 you saw the morula turn into a blastocyst. It has three parts:
- a fluid-filled cavity (the blastocoel);
- an outer layer of cells (the trophectoderm, which will form the placenta and membranes);
- a cluster of cells inside (the inner cell mass, which will form the fetus).
The Gardner system, the most widely used blastocyst grading scheme, describes each of these in one short code such as "4AB". The Istanbul consensus (2011) uses the same ideas and expects the Day 5 check at about 116 hours after insemination.
Expansion: the number
- Early blastocyst: the cavity is less than half the volume of the embryo.
- Blastocyst: the cavity is half or more of the volume.
- Full blastocyst: the cavity fills the embryo.
- Expanded: the cavity is larger than the original embryo and the zona pellucida has thinned.
- Hatching: the trophectoderm has started to herniate through the zona.
- Hatched: the blastocyst has left the zona completely.
Read the number first, because it decides whether the letters are given. Inner cell mass and trophectoderm grades are recorded for stages 3 to 6. At stages 1 and 2 the cells are not yet clearly separated, so many laboratories record the number only. Follow your laboratory's written rule and apply it the same way every time.
Inner cell mass: the first letter
- A: many cells, tightly packed.
- B: several cells, loosely grouped.
- C: very few cells.
Trophectoderm: the second letter
- A: many cells forming a cohesive layer.
- B: few cells forming a loose layer.
- C: very few, large cells.
So "4AA" is an expanded blastocyst with a well-formed inner cell mass and trophectoderm; "3BC" is a full blastocyst with a loose inner cell mass and a sparse trophectoderm. Always write the day as well. A blastocyst reaching a given stage on Day 5 and the same stage on Day 6 are recorded separately, because the clinician considers timing when choosing (page 41).
Finding the inner cell mass
The inner cell mass may sit at the top, bottom or side of the cavity. Focus slowly through the whole blastocyst before deciding that it is small or absent; you may be looking at it edge-on. If the blastocyst has collapsed (shrunk away from the zona, which can happen naturally), note "collapsed" and look again later rather than grading the shrunken form.
At the bench
- Confirm the patient and dish against the worksheet, with a witness as your laboratory requires.
- Place the culture dish on the warmed stage. Grade each blastocyst in turn: number first, then inner cell mass, then trophectoderm.
- Rotate your focus through the full depth; for a doubtful inner cell mass, use the focus rather than moving the embryo.
- Record the code, the day and the time, and any notes (collapsed, many excluded cells, vacuoles).
- Return the dish promptly. Blastocysts that are not yet graded at stage 3 may be reviewed later the same day or on Day 6, according to the plan.
In the Genesis practical you grade the same set of images more than once, days apart. You compare your own repeat grades, as well as your grades against the senior embryologist. Consistency with yourself is the first sign that you are learning.
Common errors
- Giving letters to a stage 2 blastocyst when your laboratory rule says number only.
- Grading a collapsed blastocyst as a smaller stage.
- Calling the inner cell mass "C" because it was out of focus.
- Leaving out the day, so a Day 6 blastocyst is read as Day 5.
- Writing the letters in the wrong order: inner cell mass comes first.
Key points
- The Gardner code gives an expansion number (1 to 6), then a letter for the inner cell mass, then a letter for the trophectoderm.
- Read the number first. Letters are recorded for stages 3 to 6.
- The inner cell mass letter always comes first.
- Focus through the whole blastocyst before you call the inner cell mass small or absent.
- Write the day and time with every grade. Note a collapsed blastocyst and look again later.
Check yourself
What does each of the six expansion numbers describe?
1: early blastocyst, cavity less than half the volume. 2: blastocyst, cavity half or more. 3: full blastocyst, cavity fills the embryo. 4: expanded, cavity larger than the original embryo and the zona thinned. 5: hatching, the trophectoderm herniating through the zona. 6: hatched, the blastocyst has left the zona completely.
In "5BA", which part of the blastocyst is graded B?
The inner cell mass. The first letter is the inner cell mass and the second is the trophectoderm, so the trophectoderm is graded A.
Why must the day of assessment be written with every grade?
A blastocyst reaching a stage on Day 5 and one reaching the same stage on Day 6 are recorded separately, because the clinician considers timing when choosing (page 41). Without the day, a Day 6 blastocyst can be read as Day 5.
What should you do when you meet a collapsed blastocyst?
Note "collapsed" and look again later, rather than grading the shrunken form.
From page 37: What are the three fragmentation bands in the Istanbul consensus?
Less than ten per cent, ten to twenty-five per cent, and more than twenty-five per cent (page 37).
From page 36: How does the blastocoel form?
The outer cells form tight junctions that seal the embryo and pump sodium ions inwards. Water follows by osmosis, and a fluid-filled cavity appears (page 36).
Questions on this page
What does a grade such as 4AA mean?
The number is the expansion stage (4 is expanded). The first letter grades the inner cell mass and the second the trophectoderm, A being the most cells and the most cohesive.
Are letters given to an early blastocyst?
At stages 1 and 2 the cell groups are not yet clearly formed, so many laboratories record the number only. Follow your own laboratory's written rule consistently.
Why record Day 5 and Day 6 separately?
The timing of development is part of the information the clinician weighs when choosing which embryo to transfer or freeze, so the day must never be left out.
The Genesis ART Textbook is teaching text for trainees and doctors of the Genesis ART Training Academy. It is not treatment advice and not a laboratory standard operating procedure; every technique is learned under supervision. Page numbers never change.
