Choosing a method; compromised samples
On this page you will learn
- How to choose between swim-up, density gradient centrifugation and microfluidic sorting for a given sample
- What makes a sample "compromised" and why it changes your plan
- How to handle high viscosity, low counts, poor motility, agglutination and retrograde ejaculation
- How to handle samples from men with a known blood-borne infection
- Why every choice is written down and discussed with the clinician
Start with the sample, not the habit
On pages 10 to 12 you learned three ways to prepare sperm: swim-up, density gradient centrifugation and microfluidic sorting. Each works well for some samples and poorly for others. A good andrologist does not use one method for everything.
You look at the initial assessment (pages 6 and 7) and ask three questions. How many motile sperm are there? How much debris and how many other cells are present? And what will the prepared sample be used for: IUI, conventional IVF or ICSI?
A practical way to decide
- Swim-up suits a sample with a good count and good progressive motility and little debris. It is gentle and gives a very clean fraction, but it recovers only a part of the motile sperm, so it wastes a sample that has few to spare.
- Density gradient centrifugation suits samples with lower motility, many dead or immotile sperm, round cells, debris or bacteria. It recovers a higher number of motile sperm and removes more of the unwanted material. It is the usual workhorse for IUI and IVF.
- Microfluidic sorting avoids centrifugation and selects motile sperm as they swim through channels. It is quick and gentle, but it needs a sample with enough motile sperm to start with, and the clinical evidence on its advantages is still growing (see page 12). Use it within your laboratory protocol, not as a routine upgrade.
If the post-preparation count is likely to be very low, tell the clinician before the procedure, not after. Sometimes the right decision is to change the plan, for example from IUI to IVF or ICSI (page 27 covers these indications).
Compromised samples
A compromised sample is one where the standard method is likely to fail or damage the sperm. You will meet the following often.
High viscosity
A viscous sample does not layer or spread properly and traps sperm. Allow full liquefaction at the right temperature first. If it remains viscous, the WHO laboratory manual for human semen (6th edition, 2021) describes gentle mechanical methods. Examples are passing the sample slowly through a blunt needle, or diluting it with medium. Note what you did on the worksheet, because it affects the result you report.
Low count and poor motility
With very few motile sperm, every step loses some. Choose density gradient centrifugation, use a smaller gradient volume if your protocol allows it, and resuspend the final pellet in a small volume so the sample is not over-diluted. Do not swim-up a sample that has almost nothing to swim.
Agglutination
Motile sperm stuck to each other suggests antisperm antibodies. Record the type and extent of agglutination. Density gradient preparation can release some free motile sperm, and the clinician should know about the finding.
Retrograde ejaculation
Here sperm pass into the bladder. The clinician gives instructions in advance so that the urine is less acidic, and the man passes urine after ejaculation into a container with buffered medium. You centrifuge the urine promptly to recover the sperm, then prepare them as usual. Speed matters, because urine harms sperm.
Known blood-borne infection
Samples from men who carry HIV, hepatitis B or hepatitis C are prepared under your laboratory's specific protocol: separate time slots or dedicated equipment, clear labelling, and strict universal precautions. Density gradient preparation followed by a wash is the usual basis of processing. Never improvise with these samples.
At the bench
- Read the initial assessment and the request form. Confirm the planned procedure and the time of use.
- Decide the method, write it on the worksheet with the reason, and tell the supervising embryologist if the sample is compromised.
- Warm the media you need to the temperature your protocol states, before you open the sample.
- Witness the sample identity (two identifiers on container, form and tubes) before transferring any of it.
- Prepare, keeping the time from collection to preparation within your protocol.
- Assess the result (page 14) and report to the clinician, especially if the yield is lower than expected.
Common errors
- Using swim-up out of habit on a sample with poor motility, and recovering almost nothing
- Starting preparation before liquefaction is complete
- Resuspending a poor sample in a large volume, so the concentration looks worse than it is
- Delaying the processing of a urine sample after retrograde ejaculation
- Telling the clinician about a poor yield only after the patient is already on the couch
Key points
- Choose the method from the sample, not from habit.
- Ask three questions: how many motile sperm, how much debris and how many cells, and what the sample is for.
- Swim-up suits good, clean samples; a density gradient suits poor or debris-rich samples; use microfluidics only within your protocol.
- Viscosity, low counts, agglutination, retrograde ejaculation and blood-borne infection each need a planned approach.
- Write the method and the reason on the worksheet, and warn the clinician early about a low yield.
Check yourself
A sample shows good concentration but many round cells and debris. Which method would you choose and why?
Density gradient centrifugation. It suits samples with round cells and debris, recovers more motile sperm and removes more of the unwanted material.
What two things do you do before preparing a very viscous sample?
Allow full liquefaction at the right temperature first. If it stays viscous, use a gentle mechanical method that the WHO manual describes, and note what you did on the worksheet.
Why must a urine sample for retrograde ejaculation be processed quickly?
Because urine harms sperm. You centrifuge it promptly to recover the sperm, then prepare them as usual.
When would you advise the clinician that IUI may not be the right procedure today?
When the post-preparation count is likely to be very low. Tell the clinician before the procedure, because the plan may need to change to IVF or ICSI (page 27).
From page 06: How do you assess viscosity, and what result shows that it is raised?
Draw a little sample into a wide-bore plastic pipette and let it fall drop by drop. A thread more than about 2 cm long means raised viscosity (page 6).
From page 09: What is the difference between cryptozoospermia and azoospermia?
In cryptozoospermia there are no sperm in fresh preparations, but sperm are found after centrifugation. In azoospermia no sperm are found even in the centrifuged pellet (page 9).
Questions on this page
Is one preparation method always better than the others?
No. Each method suits a different kind of sample. You choose after looking at the count, motility and debris, and the planned procedure.
What should I do if a sample is compromised?
Write down the problem and the method you chose, follow your laboratory protocol, and tell the supervising embryologist and the clinician early.
The Genesis ART Textbook is teaching text for trainees and doctors of the Genesis ART Training Academy. It is not treatment advice and not a laboratory standard operating procedure; every technique is learned under supervision. Page numbers never change.
